1.1m missed the January 31 deadline – can you appeal a penalty?

Google reviews
March 24, 2025

Around 1.1m of us missed the January 31 deadline to file our self-assessment tax returns for the 2023/24 tax year. For each person, this means at least a £100 penalty and potentially additional charges if the return continues to not be filed or the tax due paid for a longer period.

The £100 penalty is levied whether there was any tax to pay or not. It is simply for missing the deadline for filing the self-assessment return itself. If you had tax to pay though, you could also face interest charges if you also haven’t paid the bill on time.

Sole traders and partners in a partnership who contacted HMRC for help with the Basis Reform Period before December 31, 2024, should not receive a penalty as this change will make calculating their tax due more complex.

The ICAEW has been advised by HMRC that anyone in this position would have until February 28 to file their return using provisional figures without incurring a penalty. But the return should be updated when they have the correct figure and any tax due originally by January 31 that remains unpaid would face interest charges from February 1.

What other reasons would HMRC accept for late filing?

If you have a genuine reason for missing the deadline, then you should appeal any penalty. For example, if someone close to you has died – perhaps a partner or parent – then you would benefit from some leniency.

Other reasonable excuses would include:

  • You had an unexpected stay in hospital that prevented you from dealing with your tax affairs.
  • You had a serious or life-threatening illness.
  • Your computer or software failed while you were preparing your online return.
  • Issues with HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) online services.
  • A fire, flood or theft prevented you from completing your tax return.
  • Postal delays that you could not have predicted.
  • Delays related to a disability or mental illness you have.
  • You were unaware of or misunderstood your legal obligation.
  • You relied on someone else to send your return, and they did not.

Source: Gov.uk

However, these wouldn’t be considered reasonable excuses, and you wouldn’t be able to challenge the penalty if:

  • Your cheque bounced or payment failed because you did not have enough money.
  • You found the HMRC online system too difficult to use.
  • You did not get a reminder from HMRC.
  • You made a mistake on your tax return.

Source: Gov.uk

Let us help you

If you’re a Sole Trader or Contractor and you’ve missed the deadline for filing your self-assessment and have received a penalty, then please get in touch as soon as possible.

Resources

Recent Articles

Tips When Going Self-Employed As A Sole Trader

Setting up as a Sole Trader – All You Need To Know Being self-employed as a sole trader is one of the easiest ways to set up your own business. However, it’s important to take a few steps when setting up to ensure you remain compliant and...

HMRC aims to help prevent scam emails

HMRC aims to help prevent scam emails

HMRC is encouraging people to check that any email purporting to be from the taxman is genuine before you make any effort to respond and potentially fall foul of a phishing or other fraudulent email scam. It has created a page that allows you to check what emails HMRC...

Ready to join us?

Whether you’re a contractor, freelancer, or small business, Bright Ideas can help remove the burden of time-consuming and complex finances. We’ll draw on our years of knowledge and experience earned helping sole traders just like you.

When you choose us, you’ll be assigned a dedicated Account Manager who’ll provide one-on-one support that’s customised to your business. Communication is key, so we’ll always answer your questions or requests as soon as we can. In fact, we offer a same-day response guarantee for emails and calls received before 3pm.

Contact us to get started

Give us a call us or send an email today!

Looking to Switch Accountants?

Does your current accountant give 1-to-1 support? Are they fast and thorough?
Slap-dash services hold businesses back, so try our expert accountants instead. We make the transition simple, get in contact with us today and we’ll start the process.

Start the conversation

Let’s make your finances Brighter

Call us Monday to Friday 9am - 5pm

0161 669 4221

Request a call back