Resources

IR35 – where are we now?

Blog
IR35 – where are we now?

IR35 has been one of the most contentious pieces of accounting legislation since its introduction in April 2021 as HMRC works to prevent those it deems are employed by an organisation taking their income through a separate company.

Previously, any large company employing a contractor for services did not need to consider that contractor’s status for tax – it was the responsibility of the contractor, not the company to determine how that person dealt with their tax affairs. 

However, with the advent of IR35, the onus was placed instead on the company employing the contractor, which has led to a number of court cases between HMRC and those challenging this approach. The companies – known as end-users – who need to consider the IR35 position of contractors they are working with must have a turnover of more than £10.2m, a balance sheet of more than £5.1m or more than 50 employees.

What are the latest cases telling us?

There have been many cases so far where service providers using their own limited companies have chosen to legally challenge the approach taken by HMRC and their employment status under IR35. One of the latest is S & L Barnes vs HMRC. Stuart Barnes is the ex-England rugby union player who works as a pundit for Sky and uses a company to provide his services for the broadcaster, and also for the newspaper columns he writes for The Times and the Sunday Times among other work. HMRC claimed Mr Barnes owed more than £695,000 in unpaid tax and National Insurance contributions as it believed he should have been considered employed by Sky, a position he challenged.

During the 2013-14 to 2018-19 tax years, Mr Barnes earned around 60% of his income from Sky, but this subsequently fell when Sky’s rugby coverage reduced. Case precedents created in particular by the Ready Mixed Concrete case resulted in a so-called ‘three limbed’ approach being taken to determine whether someone should be considered an employee of the company. 

What does this mean?

This is a relatively complex legal method which considers whether or not the ‘employer’ has sufficient control over the employee’s work, along with a mutual obligation between the ‘employee’ providing the services and the employer who provides the work and pays for it. 

If both exist, then a further test is applied to decide whether the ‘employee’ is in a service contract, or one providing services.

In the case of Mr Barnes, the Tribunal found that he was not to be considered an employee of Sky in this instance as he had a high degree of autonomy in the way he worked with Sky, and also worked with many other organisations using his specialist rugby knowledge at specific times which he was at liberty to choose.

However, every case is different, and each turns on whether certain conditions and parameters are met. This is why the application of IR35 has been so complex for companies to understand. Yet this proves that while HMRC is determined to focus on IR35 cases, there are instances where people can be engaged for work outside of IR35.

Let us help you

If you need to determine whether someone you are working with comes under IR35 rules, then please get in touch and we can help you to get this important decision right.

To book in a FREE consultation, contact us today on 0161 669 4221 or info@biaccountancy.com.

Stay up to date on what’s new at Bright Ideas.

    Step 1 of 3

    Thanks for choosing Bright Ideas!

    Let’s get started with a few details…

    (*) Required field
    The field is required
    The field is required
    Email address is invalid
    The field is required
    By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy

    How can we help?

    I need accounting support for…

    (*) Required field
    The field is required
    The field is required
    The field is required
    The field is required
    The field is required
    £The field is required
    The field is required
    The field is required

    When’s good for you?

    Pick a slot…

    (*) Required field
    The field is required
    The field is required
    The field is required
    BACKLet's get started
    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

      Step 1 of 2

      Become a client

      Let Bright Ideas take care of your accounting. We’re guaranteed to have a solution here that suits your needs. Simply pick the package you like best and we’ll take care of the rest.

      You can sign up for our services right now. Complete the form below and we’ll be in touch the same day (if received before 4pm).

      (*) Required field
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      Email address is invalid
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy

      Let’s talk about your business

      Setting up a new business? Already trading as a Limited Company? No matter what your circumstances, Bright Ideas can help.

      (*) Required field
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required

      Included in our company formation service is:

      • Limited Company name of your choice
      • Memorandum and articles of association
      • VAT, PAYE and Corporation Tax registration
      • Certificate of incorporation and Share certificate
      • Companies house registration
      (*) Required field
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required

      Director/Shareholder

      (*) Required field
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required

      Additional director or shareholder (Should only be completed for an additional person)

      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required
      The field is required

      Declaration acceptance *

      The field is required
      The field is required
      BACKLet's get started
      This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

         

        Request a Call Back

        (*) Required field
        The field is required
        The field is required
        Email address is invalid
        The field is required
        By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy
        This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.